I was thrilled by the opportunity to have a positive impact on a new restaurant, so I pondered for a few days and eventually typed up some notes. By the time I was finished, I had a fairly lengthy message that I thought might be useful for other readers (and Googlers) as well.

I’m not posting it here not because I claim to be an expert in the area—I’m certainly not. I can actually think of several far more qualified readers who will likely chime in to tell me where I’m wrong. Really, I have two reasons for posting. First, there might be other restauranteurs out there looking for similar advice; second, because I have no doubt that I’ll be seeing some insightful comments in response. I have a feeling the comments will help turn my thoughts into something even more useful.

I realize some of you could care less about beer. If that’s you, then just ignore this post and start looking forward to the E2 post that I’m working on next.

Re: Suggestions for our beer list

NOTE: The restaurant in question plans to serve authentic Mexican cuisine. Some of my advice is directly purely at that theme, but most of it probably applies anywhere. He also didn’t want to have a huge beer list. This isn’t going to be Bocktown or even Mad Mex.

As promised, I collected some of my thoughts on beer list. I started with four pieces of general guidance and finished up with a specific list to use as a starting point. I’m hoping that will be more useful than just giving you a single list without much comment.

1. Focus on a few solid options.

I completely understand that you’re not looking to have 18 different beers on tap. There are actually a couple restaurants in the area that have been doing very well with just 4 taps (Yo Rita and Salt of the Earth come to mind). The key is to spread that selection across several style categories and keep things changing.

I think an ideal number would be 6 taps: 1 reserved for a macro lager (e.g. Yeungling). I’ve come to terms with the fact that everyone needs to carry a macro lager or two because that’s all some people drink. For a Mexican place, you could stretch to 2 macro lagers by including Negra Modelo (a half-decent macro-lager).

2. Keeping a dynamic draft list.

The beer lists that catch my attention are the ones that change over time. That gives me an incentive to head back to a restaurant to see what new stuff they have on tap. Changing a keg also makes for a good opportunity to post a notice to twitter/facebook–it’s the kind of thing your fans will help spread if they particularly like the beer.

My basic advice here would be to keep your macro lagers constant, but rotate the other four taps on a regular basis.

3. Hit a wide variety of styles.

Different beer enthusiasts have different opinions and different favorite styles. When you only have a few different beers, it’s really important to make sure that each one is from a different style.

A few of the more significant categories…

• India Pale Ale (IPA)
  (a very popular category, so it’s important to have at least one)
• Stout / Porter
  (very dark/roasty styles)
• Pilsner
  (hoppy but light bodied style out of Germany)
• Wheat
  (hefeweizen, American wheat—goes over well for those who don’t like beer)
• Seasonal
  (have an Oktoberfest in Sept and a winter/spiced ale leading up to Christmas)
• Amber Lager
  (märzen/Oktoberfest/Vienna lager–works very well for Mexican cuisine)
• Dark Lager
  (bock/dunkel–a more mild lager with some history in Mexico)
• Belgian
  (usually bigger beers with spicy/fruity flavors left over from warm fermentations)

The amber and dark lager categories work especially well with Mexican cuisine because much of Mexico’s historic brewing tradition was brought by German immigrants. For example, Negra Modella is actually a decent example of a German Dunkel.

4. Connect with the local brewers

There’s a big push for staying local these days, and beer is no exception. Pittsburgh (and more generally PA) has a number of great local/regional brewers. If you carry something from the local brewers, many will make a point to tell their fans. They want to sell their beer just as much as you do.

The most notable local brewer is probably East End Brewing, but there are others out there to keep in mind as well.

Some local Pittsburgh brewers:

• East End Brewing Company
• Full Pint Brewing Company
• Penn Brewery
• Church Brew Works

Some well-liked brewers in the region:

• Tröegs Brewing Company (Harrisburgh, PA)
• Victory Brewing Company (Downingtown, PA)
• Stoudts Brewing Company (Adamstown, PA)
• Great Lakes Brewing Company (Cleveland, OH)
• Weyerbacher Brewing Company (Easton, PA)
• Erie Brewing Company (Erie, PA)
• Lancaster Brewing Company (Harrisburg, PA)
• Sly Fox Brewing Company (Royersford, PA)
• Roy Pitz Brewing Company (Chambersburg, PA)

5. A good list to start with

To give an example, I’ll throw out the beer list that I would use if I were starting a Mexican restaurant with 6 taps.

Suggested Drafts:

• Negra Modello (Dark Lager, to appease people wanting something Mexican)
• Yeungling Lager (Light Lager, to appease people wanting a macro lager)
• East End Big Hop (IPA, for the hop heads in the crowd)
• Great Lakes Elliot Ness (Vienna Lager, a good medium-body lager in a Mexican-friendly style)
• Bell’s Porter (American Porter, for the guy asking about something dark)
• Penn Weizen (Hefeweizen, a damn-good  example of the style for the wheat-beer fans)

(option 1-prime, for once your up and running: Penn Dark, which is a better example of a dark lager)

If you wanted to keep a few bottles around, you could appease a few other common requests. I think things like Corona and other typical Mexican requests might help out with the portion of your audience looking for that sort of thing.

NOTE: I should point out here that the self-proclaimed beer novice tipped his hand just a little bit here and threw out some great additional ideas for Mexican options: Bohemia and Nochebuena. Both would probably be fantastic additions for the bottle list if he can’t get them in kegs. If he can get by without stooping to the level of Corona, then I’d be thrilled.

…

Anyway, those are my thoughts. Others may have different opinions, so I tried to keep my high level advice general. If have questions or ever want a few more specific recommendations, I’d be happy to help out.

–Mike

Park Bruges
www.pointbrugge.com

5801 Bryant St
Pittsburgh, PA 15206
(412) 661-3334

Park Bruges, you might notice, uses a different spelling of “Bruges;” that would be the French spelling instead of the Flemish “Brugge” variant. The reported plan is to point their Highland Park outpost in the direction of Belgium’s French community and leave Point Breeze location with all of its Flemish tendencies in tact. Like the original, Park Bruges still serves up a quality beer list of mostly Belgian bottles with a relatively small Belgian-focused draft list and a few American craft options for those who want it. In other words, it’s the Highland Park destination I’ve been waiting for.

Not that any of the existing highland park destinations is at all bad.

Interior Scene—with apologies for the lousy quality

Modern, casual, and still small. I admit it: I don’t go to Point Brugge nearly as often as I should. My friends say the Park variant is a little larger, but I’m not sure I buy it. They’re both relatively small and both jam-packed—even on a week night. Park Bruges has a decidedly different exterior: a big sidewalk-level window opens up the whole restaurant to outside onlookers, but otherwise, the exterior is fairly non-descript. I had to get pretty close before I was even certain that I had found the right restaurant.

Once you get inside, the setting is fairly bright—much more so than Point Brugge. A medium-sized bar lines the right wall with tables occupying the remaining thin strip of a restaurant. I went on a Wednesday night about 2 weeks after they opened and the place was reasonably packed. I had to wait about 15 minutes for a table, which isn’t all that bad on the Point Brugge scale. At least we know the business is doing well.

Saison Dupont (i.e., happiness)

The full bottle list (click to zoom)

Belgian bottles and then some. The beer list is actually fairly large—but almost entirely focussed on bottles. There are only 6-8 taps, and there doesn’t seem to be any effort to list them on the menu. You really just have to walk up to the bar and look. The bottle list, on the other hand, is well published (see above). There’s a printed list on every table, and it’s filled with a wide assortment of Belgian options. The list is segmented by style with Belgians up front and a combination of American craft options and imports starting beyond the fold. I was actually fairly surprised to see that they had 12 oz. version of many Belgians that typically come in larger bottles—including the Saison Dupont that I ordered.

Simple menu with a few veggie options. The menu is relatively small—just two pages. On the front, you find appetizers and a few salads; on the back, entrees and sandwiches. In terms of veggie options, they serve a house-made veggie burger and a vegetable-based ratatoullie farfalle. On the appetizer list, they have a few more options—most notably the Organic Pheonix Tofu: napa cabbage and tofu with a soy-ginger sauce and peanut garnish. In terms of poutine, they serve up a “classic montreal” version with no added meat, but it’s still drenched in gravy and hence, not so vegetarian.

Traditional Poutine

Grölsch style water dispensing

Poutine. When I went, I ordered a few different items—starting with the much talked-about poutine. The poutine was…interesting. Thin, but not crispy fries resting in a wide bowl atop a puddle of gravy—all topped with cheese curds. Cheese curds, you say? Yes. That would be the solid portion of curds and whey: a kind of proto-cheese before any sort of aging. By virtue of the gravy, this definitely wasn’t a vegetarian dish but I wanted to sample to see what the dish was all about. I’ve heard some comment that the fries different from those at Point Brugge. According to First Bites, it’s true: they’re intentionally thinner to accommodate the poutine.

The poutine honestly wasn’t nearly the monstrosity I imagined: the cheese curds were applied somewhat lightly, and the fries certainly weren’t drenched in gravy. Instead, the gravy just happened to be floating below the fries in case you wanted to take one of them in for a more extensive dip. If you’re not strictly veg, I would recommend giving it a try—if for no other reason than to impress your Canadian friends.

Grilled Flat Iron (with a portabella substitution)

Spinach Salad, with fruit :-(

A portabello substitute of a salad. I didn’t want to mound carbs on top of carbs, so I was aiming for a salad. Of the two entree salads, one featured fruit and the other featured steak. Not being a fan of fruit on my salad, I opted for the steak—though with a request that they might substitute portobello. My server took the request without issue and brought out a beautiful salad that made it look like portobello was the default option. I was impressed.

Beyond appearance, the salad was outstanding. Caramelized onions, home fries, blue cheese, tossed very lightly in a champagne vinaigrette. The lettuce was fresh, and everything was well in balance. I’d say it was one of the better salads I’ve had in Pittsburgh. My housemate and dining companion, Brett, like fruit on his salad. He ordered the spinach salad with strawberries and pears and seemed to be quite happy with the results as well.

I’m an enormous fan of Park Bruges. In every aspect that I care about, they delivered. The service was attentive and friendly, the atmosphere was casual and easy-going, the beer list was superb, and the food was well presented. If you’re looking for good quality Franco-Belgian cuisine—or even if you just want to try some poutine, you definitely need to head over to Park Bruges and try the place out. I’d even go so far as to rating it as a must-try kind of place.

In the particular case of Pi Coal Fired, the results were mixed: great pizza, plenty of veggie options, and even a few craft beer options. The pizza was even fairly healthy—very well balanced without being overcome by a thick layer of cheese. That’s not to say the place is perfect—you need to tolerate a few (manageable) shortcomings along the way, but I still recommend checking it out.

Pi Coal Fired
www.picoalfired.com

1707 E. Carson St
Pittsburgh, PA 15203
(412) 431-5095

There seem to be quite a few people who had never heard of Pi Coal Fired. Given their proximity to some other well-known South Side destinations, that’s a little surprising. They’re right on Carson near 17th Street—somewhere between Fat Heads and Carson Street Deli. Based on a City Paper commentary, it sounds like they opened in February 2010 with a goal of bringing great Neapolitan pizza to the South Side. I think they manage to meet that goal—with one caveat: the restaurant is attached to a night club (Jimmy D’s). That association has a somewhat significant impact on the overall atmosphere, but I’ll dive into that issue a little later.

A little hard to find, and a little empty. Some places in the South Side have a rather substantial sign out front. Pi Coal Fired isn’t one of those places. They have a small self-standing sign on the front sidewalk and the restaurant name printed on the front canopy. That’s really it. You can look in through the front windows and see a rather nice interior with a substantial bar along the right side, but it’s still not clear what to expect: they could offer a good beer list, or not; They could serve good food, or not. It’s unclear.

On my first visit, I stepped in and found the place nearly empty—with the bar tender being the only visible employee and only one table actually filled with guests. A big opening in the back of the restaurant gives a pretty good view into the kitchen—including the brick pizza oven, but I didn’t notice a lot of activity back there. Luckily, things picked up when I asked for a menu and grabbed a table.

A highly focussed menu. One of the counter-intuitive indicators of a questionable restaurant is a large and diverse menu. There aren’t many restaurant kitchens out there that can really show mastery over every item on an enormous menu, so a big menu often foreshadows a wide selection of mediocrity. Pi seems to avoid that trap with a highly focused menu: they serve a few basic salads, but only as accompaniments to an assortment of pizzas and calzones. If you’re interested, you can check out the full lineup on their web site.

Toppings for the pizzas and fillings for the calzones focus on a small number of traditional Italian staples: roasted red pepper, prosciutto, mozzarella, mushroom, pickled peppers, sausage, and various fresh herbs. I was pleasantly surprised that very nearly half of the available options were vegetarian by default. They have a tendency to throw in some prosciutto in a couple of pies that seemed otherwise vegetarian-leaning, so it feels like several additional options could go veggie rather easily if you asked for it.

Salad Della Casa

Caprese Pizza

Surprisingly good salad. I opted for both a salad and a pizza: the salad della casa and a caprese pizza. I’ll be the first to admit that I had low expectations for the salad. That’s probably why I was so surprised to receive a plated piled high with fresh arugula and a light dusting of almonds, tomatoes, and toasted bits of prosciutto. Note the prosciutto: it was only a minor player but you’d have to put in a request for a strictly veggie option. The tomato preparation was notable: I’m guessing they were fire-roasted and shrivled cherry tomatoes that had been cut into small wedges.

Contrary to my initial expectation, the salad was great. It was nearly as good as the ingredient list makes it sound, though the 100% arugula could very easily be too much. My biggest complaint would be the dressing—it was a good balsamic vinaigrette, but it had been applied with a somewhat heavy hand. On the second visit, the dressing situation was a little more tolerable—though I still wish I could actually remember to request it on the side.

Arugula Pizza

Funghi Pizza

Sophisticated pizza. From reading the restaurant’s web site and the owner’s rather ballsy (but respectable) response to some Urbanspoon criticism, it’s pretty clear that they care about their pizza. From their insistence on very specific ingredients (Tipo 00 Flour, San Marzano Tomatoes) to strict adherence to Neapolitan style guidelines, they make a strong effort to present a classic Neapolitan pie. I don’t have much to compare it to, but what they do serve adheres rather well to what Peter Reinhart describes—and his word tends to be law when it comes to all things dough.

Beyond adherence to a particular style, the pizza is good. When you think pizza, it’s pretty easy to imagine crust reminiscent of cardboard topped with bland sauce and a thick greasy layer of cheese. That’s not what you get at Pi. Here, the pizza is exceptionally thin, but yet not all that crispy. Thanks to the high heat of a coal fired brick oven, the pizza carried a few attractive char marks but the interior was still soft and somewhat chewy—that’s where the finely milled 00 flour really shines through.

The various toppings are added with a great deal of restraint. For example, my caprese pizza included a very thin layer of sauce, a few splotches of fresh mozzarella, a few slices of tomato, and fresh basil leaves tossed on after baking. No one ingredient was overdone, so you could easily pick out several layers of flavor without being overwhelmed by any single topping. I also went home without feeling all that guilty about having a few slices.

Draft Options (there's no printed list)

They need to figure out the beer thing. I absolutely love that a good beer list is becoming more the norm and less the exception, and Pi follows that trend with what appears on the surface to be a pretty good beer list, but only on the surface. With 21 draft options, you might think there has to be something good. That’s only partially true. Yes, they had some good craft options on the list (e.g., Rogue Dead Guy and Lagunitas IPA), but they also had an inordinate number of macros (e.g., Labatte Blue, Newcastle Brown Ale, Stella Artois). There are enough good options that I could pick something but it was a little harder than I expected at first.

A mediocre blend of options wouldn’t necessarily be a show-stopper: the real problem here was the quality of the output. Most of the beers I tried were served far too cold, stale, and often riddled with other off flavors—to the point of wondering whether they pay any attention to cleaning their draft lines. I think there are a few problems here: 1) they need to take better care of their beer and beer lines, and 2) they don’t get enough traffic to turn over a keg in a reasonable amount of time. I’m really hoping that over time, they’ll work to solve problem (1) and the community will reward them by solving problem (2).

More on the night club problem. In the Post-Gazette’s review, Munch called Pi Schizophrenic—in the sense that the place couldn’t figure out if it was a quality pizza destination or night club bar. I very much agree with that complaint. The audience for each type of establishment has very different expectations and rarely overlaps. On both of my visits, there were several hints of night club that called out from just below the surface. The club feel wasn’t overwhelming but the run-down bathrooms and aforementioned beer problems can definitely fall into that category of “club-ishness.” That, and I would be a little afraid of stopping by on a Friday or Saturday night.

I’m rooting for them. My feelings on Pi are mixed. I can definitely say I like the place, and I would even go so far as to say that they deserve far more attention and far more praise than they have received so far. The food and staff were excellent, but a variety of beer problems and an unsettling “club feel,” though not overwhelming, both serve to detract from the overall experience. I, like Munch, really hope they make take steps to clean up their act on both fronts. With a few minor course corrections, I think Pi could be a great place—and I’m definitely rooting for them to succeed.

Fiddler’s Bar and Grill
www.fiddlersbarandgrill.com

9101 Perry Hwy
Pittsburgh, PA 15237
(412) 635-2300

You may already know Fiddler’s by another name: Magoo’s. That seems to have been the name of the restaurant before their recent re-branding. The ownership hasn’t changed, and I’m told the interior hasn’t either. The “big” change is really a slight modernization of the menu. As far as I can tell, that’s code for a few veggie-friendly options plus some 90′s-era foodie highlights: sun-dried tomatoes, goat cheese, and the like. It’s still not a vegetarian or foodie mecca, but the slightly modernized options are welcome.

Not quite hidden up North. The North Hills is a broad region, so I’ll define the location a little more clearly: Perry Highway in McCandless Township—a little South from where Mcknight splits off. The building is well marked, so it’s not hard to find if you’re on the right road. The parking lot is somewhat disorganized but seems to have plenty of space.

Inside, the restaurant is pretty well separated between the bar (near the main entrance) and a big dining room (on the opposite side). I’m guessing the two sections are split 1/3 – 2/3 with the dining room winning out for the large space. On both sides, the tables are clean and ready for customers—with place-settings set neatly on each table in the dining room. My only real problem with the layout was the lack of a host table or obvious way to grab a table, which could have made for some confusion had I been going for a table in the dining room.

Doubly awesome bar tender. On both of my visits, I just stuck to the bar an ordered food there. It’s hard to suggest that a bar-experience says anything about the waitstaff, but I can at least say that service at the bar was excellent: friendly, full of both food and beverage suggestions, and more than able to describe any of of the draft options. There’s a huge difference between restaurant staff that awkwardly keeps their distance and those that know they can but in and comment. The bar tender made for a good example of the more personable type.

That same bar tender took care of the beer meetup (no easy undertaking) and really went above and beyond in making our event fun. She kept everyone’s glasses full, made us smile, and even washed and distributed our free Troegs pint glasses from @DMWatters as we packed up to leave. On both occasions, the Fiddler’s staff really showed that they cared about keeping customers happy.

Free Troegs Glasses from @DMWatters

About that modernized menu. The menu lists the standard fare for a casual bar and grill: assorted appetizers, soup, salad, burgers, sandwiches. The only outlier was the flatbreads, which are really just assorted toppings baked onto a roughly square sheet of dough. The result is something much like a white pizza with toppings that seem to draw from a deli (spinach, pesto, sun dried tomato, cheese steak and a few others).

As far as menu changes go, I don’t have an old menu to compare but that doesn’t stop me from guessing. I have a hunch that the fish taco and sun dried tomato appetizers are among the menu’s new additions. The dinner salad with shrimp and cilantro-lime vinnaigrette is another candidate for a fairly recent introduction. The Tribune-Review (my source of the “modernization” claim) also seems to indicate that the entire flat breads section can be counted among the new menu arrivals. Giving some of the toppings, that seems to make sense as well.

Vegetarians beware. I always try to make a point to call out healthy and/or veggie-leaning menu items, but that’s honestly one of Fiddlers’ stumbling points. There are a two vegetarian appetizers, but it’s not clear that either is even moderately healthy. The sundried tomato and goat cheese hummus might be reasonable—depending on the level of goat cheese, but it’s hard to imagine the spinach and artichoke dip will leave your calorie budget in tact. The balsamic roasted vegetable wrap was really the only other menu item to catch my eye. There are a few other vegetarian flat breads and entrees, but nothing that I can really get excited about. They don’t even offer a vegetarian dinner salad.

I’m lucky in the sense that I have no problem eating fish, and the Fiddler’s menu opens up quite a bit if you welcome the sea into your diet. The mahi mahi fish tacos instantly grabbed my attention; as did the seared salmon and cilantro-lime shrimp salads. Other options were interesting, but not particularly attention grabbing.

Mahi Mahi Fish Tacos

My fascination with fish tacos. For whatever reason, I find myself drawn to the the fish taco. Everyone has their own interpretation, so it’s the type of item that you can try at 10 different places to find 10 completely different constructions. That also makes it a good indicator of any restaurant’s capacity for creative presentation. In the case of Fiddler’s, the specific menu item was a set of three mahi mahi tacos—as an appetizer. I would call them more of a meal.

My tacos had some positive execution points but also some negatives. First, the presentation was lackluster. The rolled tortilla exteriors served to hide each taco’s contents while tiny lime slices (not wedges) sat awkwardly between each roll. Compare that presentation to something like the Sharp Edge and you’ll know why I’m complaining. Flavor-wise, the fish was nicely cooked: flaky but not without texture. There was a slight hint of heat that felt a little like a sprinkle of cayenne, but that heat had to compete with a little more salt than I would hope for.

On the plus side, the tacos did feature a nice spicy slaw with a mostly vinegar base—the way all fish tacos should be. Overall, the tacos weren’t at all bad; they just exhibited some room for improvement. With a little less salt and a more appealing presentation, I wouldn’t have any reason to complain.

On flatbread. I had a chance to try a piece of some of the flat bread while I was at the beer meetup. I don’t have too much to say, but I wanted to at least note that they were better than I expected. The cheese and toppings were applied with a great deal of restraint, so the resulting dish was well balanced and less unhealthy than expected. The bread was a little on the thick side, but there was still room for a variety of flavors to merge into each bite.

Some Tap Hanldes

Oh, the beer list. Fiddler’s is rather short on drafts—I counted only 8. Two slots go to macro-lagers, two go to Yuengling and Guinness, so only four are left open for real craft beer options. The remaining four were all good beers with a decidedly local trend: Oskar Blues Old Chub, Troegs Hop-Back, Erie Ol’ Red, and Victory something or other. Of course, the four craft drafts aren’t the only options: about 20 bottle options supplement that list with stuff from Dogfish, Great Lakes, and several others. Overall, the list was pretty reasonable, though it’s clear they need more throughput to support more kegs and faster turnaround on the kegs they have. That’s really the chicken and egg problem of the craft beer world.

I like Fiddlers. That’s not to say the place is a new favorite or the next destination for the Blogger meetup. Really, it just means that they’re doing more than a few things right. The menu could use a few more veggie options and the food has a little room for improvement, but they seem focussed on making things better. With a decent beer list, free WiFi, and an amazing staff, it’s the kind of place that can very easily draw me back. That lands them squarely in the category of worth a shot.

Over the past few years, we’ve grown as a city. A burst of casual fine dining has brought quality food without the oppressive atmosphere; dynamic, often seasonal, menus have become the norm. More in line with my interests, some of the city’s best restaurants have even started opening previously bland draft lists to more interesting beer options. I would even say it has become a little rare to find draft list dominated entirely by industrialized adjunct lagers.

Shiloh Grill
www.theshilohgrill.com

123 Shiloh Street
Pittsburgh, PA 15211
(412) 431-4000

In many ways, I view the current owners of Harris Grill as an early example of those trends: they’ve had a great beer list for as long as I can remember and casual is the rule of their game. The food is notable, but probably not exceptional—at least relative to my own biases. It’s all well prepared and consistent, just not the type of food I usually go for. For example, you’ve probably heard of “bacon night” (Tuesday).

Despite the caloric minefield, there are some healthful options—even good number of vegetarian options. Whatever your leanings, you’re more than likely to find something that fits your diet—unless you’re dead set on vegan options, which are shamelessly bashed on their menu. Of course, Harris has always augmented that culinary baseline with a dynamic list of draft beer options and moderately impressive list of bottles. Merge the food with good beer and you have a place worth getting excited about.

What does Harris Grill have to do with the Shiloh? Everything. The same owners that made Harris Grill what it is today are renting the space that was formerly Shiloh Inn. At the end of last year, they opened it back up in the image of Harris. Actually, the renovation was completed so quickly that I didn’t even hear about it until it was finished (via Bill Toland’s story in the Post Gazette). By that time, Grill #2 was basically up and running, and I had no choice but to go check it out.

Eerily similar setup. The scenery at Shiloh Grill is strikingly similar to what you might find at the Ellsworth location: two floors, similar decorations, and even a front porch (really, more of a deck). They also share the same branding: the flame logo.

I didn’t spend much time on Shiloh’s first floor, but I did note that the second floor feels just a little bit nicer than Harris—even a little bit upscale. That’s not to say it’s any less laid back—the web site assures that point with a rather loose dress code for their new year’s party. That is to say that I noted the tables are a bit more spread out and the walls are a bit brighter—with two-person tables positioned next to eat of several smaller windows. The working fireplace drives the upscale point even a little further.

By the way, if you’re looking for the that dress code: “proper attire consists of keeping the bathing suit areas covered at all times while on premises.” I see no similar rules on the Harris site, which I suspect just means they’re fending off any stuffy Mt Washington expectations. For humor value alone, I hope they keep it up for a little while.

Craft beer before it was cool. Don’t get me wrong, craft beer was always cool; it’s just getting easier and easier to find good beer in Pittsburgh’s restaurants. The Harris Grill was an early adopter of that trend, and Shiloh Grill maintains the same focus. Though not listed on the web site, I seem to recall about a dozen draft options and multiple pages of bottles—all conveniently organized by style.

Perhaps even more notable than a good beer list is a staff that has something to say about it. It’s easy to add a few beers to the menu but much harder to nurture a culture that embraces it. I’ve been to far too many restaurants with waitstaff—and the even bar tenders—are completely unable to accurately describe something from the draft list. Neither of the Grills is like that. On my most recent visit to Harris and my first visit to Shiloh, I ended up with a server that really knew something about beer. At Shiloh, I even ended up chatting with our waiter about homebrew.

That all-important server rapport. I have never met a Harris or Shiloh employee that I didn’t like. The servers are truly amazing, and the people I worked with to plan a beer meetup bent over backwards for our group. Even beyond knowing something about beer, the servers are consistently on-key and friendly. They are keenly aware of the perfect amount of conversation and interesting enough that you want to go back just to see your server again. To drive that point home, I’m still facebook friends with our server from the beer meetup.

Bar food with attitude. Reading the menu for either restaurant is always entertaining. Filled with cultural references and irreverent commentary, it’s worth spending some time reading over the whole thing. Somewhat ironically, my favorite piece of humor is the one that comes closest to making fun of me. There’s an icon for menu items that are both dairy free and gluten free—and also suitable to NPR listeners: that icon just doesn’t appear anywhere outside of the key. Also, said icon is a soviet-style hammer and sickle. Laughing at yourself is a good thing.

Veggie-friendly, but often unhealthy. Like I said up top: beyond the humor value, I have mixed feelings about the menu’s contents (pdf). On one hand, it shows off vegetarian options in just about every section. At the same time, a number of those options are anything but healthy—good for some but somewhat counter to my own goals. Remember, I lean veg for health reasons more than anything else. Between that and bacon night, they’re catering to a crowd that’s willing to throw health out the window. That said, the Shiloh menu does list a few options that caught my attention, and I’m sure they’ll all find their way into a future visit: “labor-inducing vegetarian chili,” “quickie salad chop chop” (though I’d skip the bacon/chicken), and the “garden weasel.”

To start, the Calamari Mata Hari. Proving that I’m pretty far from actually being a vegetarian (or even much of a health nut), we ended up starting with a fried calamari appetizer. This was was well presented with a bit of a twist: rather than any type of dipping option, the fried tentacles were pre-blended with a curry-based seasoning. The flavor was a unique twist that made for an appetizer well worth trying.

For dinner, A Craw Full of Falafel. I’ll give this dish a second-best rating. The falafel was good, but the sandwich somewhat sparse. There wasn’t much content beyond sauce and a sparse treatment of diced cucumber and tomato. That lack of variety left a sandwich with limited flavor depth and not nearly enough veggies. The flatbread substrate wasn’t anything to write home about either. Overall, the sandwich wasn’t bad—it just could have been much better.

I did have the option to use a garden salad as my side. I did, and it was overflowing with some nice greens and fresh veggies—not to mention a pretty good vinaigrette on the side. I’ve actually started to see more and more iceberg lettuce cropping up in salads around town, but the side salad at Harris ignored that trend: half my plate was filled with mixed field greens. That salad experience foretold good things of their entree salads, which I would love to hit up on a future visit.

Calimari Mata Hari

A Craw Full of Falafel

On the other side of the table, the Garden Weasel. I think Emily made the better choice on dinner with her vegetable-filled sandwich. The weasel is basically a ciabatta roll stuffed with a pile of veggies. It was bursting several layers of flavor. Between the mozzarella and pesto mayo, it’s less healthy than a salad but still well worth the points—certainly more so than my falafel. I would definitely order it again—sometime when I’m not in the mood for a salad.

The Twinkiemissou. Almost. The dessert menu (pdf) lists multiple options that fall into the category of things I wouldn’t normally subject myself to. One in particular is probably the last thing I would ever imagine ordering: “Twinkiemissou.” Naturally, we order it—or at least tried to. As it turns out, they were out of said dessert and offered up a pumpkin roll instead. We went for it, and I was pleasantly surprised. The pumpkin roll flaunted a thoughtful presentation and plenty of flavor. Overall, it was a dessert wroth eating: just like the pumpkin roll you would want to see at an autumn-themed party.

The Garden Weasel—with "tater tots"

The Shiloh-branded pumpkin roll

Overall. I’ll be the first to admit that neither of the Grills’ menus is catering to my tastes, but I do think the entree salads hold promise. That’s probably exactly what I’m ordering next time. Even the hope for some goo salads makes an important point: the grills both serve something for everyone. They somehow manage to please everyone from me (the salad’s biggest fan) to someone more likely to drool over bacon night. That’s no easy task, and I respect any restaurant that can pull it off. Add some beer and an indescribably amazing staff, and you have a restaurant worth getting excited about. I would even call the Shiloh/Harris pair a must-try pair: you owe it to yourself to check at least one of them out.

Rugger’s Pub
www.ruggerspub.com (a work in progress)

40 S. 22nd St.
Pittsburgh, PA 15203
(412) 381-1330

Ruggers first came to my attention on Twitter, after I bumped into one of their bar tenders at the PodCamp after-party (@pghrugbyangel). Based on the limited information I could dig up on the web, Ruggers seemed like exactly the kind of place I like to seek out: the under-appreciated and somewhat unknown local joint. After that initial digging and some friendly Twitter-prompting from Claire, I decided to give it a shot.

The “Ruggers” name highlights backing from several members of the Pittsburgh Rugby Club. I’ve also heard that it’s owned by the same guy that owns Patrick’s Pub up in Moon Township. It’s certainly not really a foodie destination—or even a beer destination, for that matter. Instead, Ruggers is more of a relaxed bar that manages to steer clear of some of the South Side’s more obnoxious revelers. Similar places can be found both on and off Carson Street, but the crowd at Ruggers is distinctly different: a little younger and a little more interested in good beer and better food. Perhaps even more significantly, the menu is far more than a little vegetarian-friendly.

Not a full-sized restaurant. The space is familiar: an elongated corridor with the bar running almost the full length and a handful of tables along the opposing wall. The kitchen, bathrooms, an extra table and a juke box are all packed in toward the back. With limited bar tables—easily outnumbered by seats at the bar, there’s really no need for a designated wait staff; both times I went for food, I just stopped up by the bar and asked for a menu.

Back Half of the Bar

The staff is friendly, though chatty. They seem to occupy a common social circle, so it’s easy to show up and find the most interesting conversation taking place behind the bar. If there’s no one else around, I can’t blame them—it just makes for an odd environment to pull out a laptop and work.

Minimally annoying WiFi. Speaking of my laptop, the WiFi network is free—though protected by a password. I’ll be kind enough to leave the password out of my review, but it’s the kind of thing you only need to ask for once. Easy to pull up on a second visit. I’ll be the first to say that any WiFi password is moderately annoying but probably sensible. That said, a static password is still far more welcome situation than the time-limited Green Light service I’ve run into in some places.

A handful of smokers. I’ll probably be called out if I don’t mention the smoke, so I’ll come out and say it: Ruggers is a somewhat smoker-friendly bar. That’s not to say it’s entirely smoke-filled or that everyone in there is smoking: it just means that you might run into someone smoking at the bar. I don’t consider smoking to be a big deal: for whatever reason, it never bothers me. If it does bother you, then at least you’ve been warned.

Plenty of craft beer draghts. For a small place with just a handful of draft options, the beer list is really quite good. They have a nice representation of styles from Edmund Fitzgerald (my favorite porter) to the Church Brew Works Celestial Gold. In the time since my last visit, the Ruggers site is even online—listing more draft options than I knew they had space for. They certainly aren’t afraid of to run a Labatt special during a Penguins game, but adjunct lagers are certainly in the minority.

Front Side of the Bar

Standard menu with some veggie options. The menu isn’t online for me to review in detail, but it certainly doesn’t contain any surprises—except perhaps it’s size. For a small place with a tiny kitchen, the menu is actually fairly large. I found sandwiches, salads, wraps, burgers, and soup. Rumor has it, the veggie burger is made in-house (not just a frozen patty). I’ve also found that their salads are pleasantly large: even the half-sized salad is around the size of any other restaurant’s entree salad.

First trip: the veggie wrap. The first time I hit up Ruggers, I ordered a veggie wrap. Filled with pieces of Ruggers’ homemade veggie burger, grilled pepper and onion, and even some tomato sauce, there were definitely a number of flavors floating around inside. I’m not one to order fries, but I noticed that pickle chips happened to be an option. Not having ever heard of (or consumed) a pickle chip, I went for it. I’d say the pickle chips were interesting, but probably not worth the points. The wrap was good, though. A nice non-salad option for vegetarians. I won’t say it was exceptional, but I’d definitely order it again.

Veggie Wrap with Pickle Chips

Second trip: the garden veggie salad. My second trip was an odd day for me: a Saturday with a mixed up schedule. I ended up at Ruggers on a Saturday afternoon (around 3pm). It was still light out, and I was basically the only person there. That gave me a chance to get some decent photos and a chance to try another menu item: the garden veggie salad. Afraid it might be a tiny salad, I tried to order an entree version. The bar tender warned that even the half-portion was huge. With that input, I opted for the half-salad—and was surprised to see that it was about the same size as any other restaurant’s entree salad. I would be afraid to even see what the full-sized salad looks like.

Though the salad was big and topped with all sorts of vegetables, I must say it carried an off flavor that I couldn’t quite place. If I had to guess, I would say it came from the roasted pepper topping—which obviously came from a jar. If I ordered again, I’d likely opt to go without the peppers. There were plenty of other vegetables anyway.

Garden Veggie Salad

I’m a supporter. Ruggers is the type of place I like to support: Local, different, and trying to do the right thing. Their staff seems to care about making customers happy, and the menu can be taken in any direction you like: veggie options, enormous salads, soup, or even more traditional bar fare. I won’t say the food is anything write home about, but I will say the beer list is surprising. If smoke bothers you, then I imagine you’ll just stay away; other than that, I’d say it’s worth a shot. If you’re tired of some of the other Carson Street mainstays, then I’d say it’s definitely time to give Ruggers a try.

I’ve been sitting on my notes from my most recent visit for way too long, and the addition of beer definitely means they could use another quick mention. They’re not perfect, but they represent a tend that I can get behind: a low key stop to get some dinner, catch up on email, and enjoy a quality beer.

Carson Street Deli
www.carsonstreetdeli.com

1507 E Carson St
Pittsburgh, PA 15203
(412) 381-5335

Carson Street Deli is nothing new to frequent visitors to the South Side. They’ve been sitting in the same spot and serving up some pretty good deli sandwiches for as long as I’ve been paying attention. They were even a long-time source of Free WiFi (the focal point of my previous write-up).

The big change appeared when home-brewer and beer enthusiast Mike Murphy stepped in and bought the place. Unlike many ownership changes, he didn’t change much at all. The menu remains entirely unchanged, and the WiFi is just as free as ever. The one change he did make was the addition of beer. Without shifting the general layout, Mike squeezed four taps and three coolers full of assorted bottles. Carson Street Deli (CSD) still isn’t anywhere close to a bar; it’s a deli that just happens to serve beer. I think that’s a good thing.

A few good drafts. It’s the beer that changed, so I’ll start there. Being a deli, there’s very little room for much of a draft system; most of the options appear in bottle form. I counted about three coolers opposite the counter all filled with a much wider selection of beer than you would expect in such a limited space. All four draft options are served from behind the counter and include a decent spread of 100% good craft beer. On the night I went, Mike was even pimping an exceptional Belgian Pale Ale. Looking back in his facebook timeline, it seems that night’s list included two Belgians and two American Craft beers that night. Mike is a bit of a hop-head (but he should really start announcing his draft list on Twitter).

Don’t expect to find a bunch of six packs. To maximize space, each type of beer is filed into just one or two rows of bottles. The actual bottle list is more varied than I would have expected. Most bottle shops I visit fall into a familiar theme of a bottle list—shaped largely by their distributor of choice. That didn’t quite feel like the case at CSD. I found a wide range of bottles—including a few options I don’t always run into in Pittsburgh. There’s clearly some passion (and effort) in deploying the list.

Numerous options in just a few coolers

Not much to say about the menu. Deli sandwiches ($6-7) and deli sides ($2-4) round out the entirety of the list. Among those options, I found a handful of vegetarian options, but was hard pressed to find much in the way of a garden salad. Salad toppings may be harder to keep, but the lack of a meal-sized lettuce salad creates a bit of a barrier for me. There are some nights when I’d just rather stick with a light salad—especially if I’m ordering a beer.

Each sandwich specifies a suggested type of bread, but they are only suggestions: the staff seemed happy to switch in the bread of my choosing. In following the trending lead, they also offer to toss any sandwich in the panini press (for another $1).

UPDATE: Turns out, I was wrong on the comment about a lack of salads. CSD offers fresh salads during the day, but pull them out of the display at night. If you twist their arm a little, it sounds like they’d be more than willing to pull one out for you. As with anywhere else, the best way to keep their salads fresh: go there and order one. Show them that you care about good beer and good salad.

Grilled cheese for the beer pairing

When I am up for a sandwich, CSD does a decent job. Because they carry more veggie options than the average deli, it’s fairly easy to skip the meat. For my last write-up I picked up a basic Vegetarian Sandwich on a French baguette. While perfectly good, that choice represents the least interesting veggie option on the list. It’s easily trumped by a black bean baguette (the Veggie “Burger”), a hummus and veggie filled pita (the Veggie Deluxe), or a more Italian-themed Veggie Roma with mozzarella and a few veggies in another French Baguette.

I won’t say that the sandwich list is groundbreaking, but I prefer the quality breads and myriad fillings at CSD to the oversized grease bombs and commoditized cheese steaks of Pittsburgh’s better known sandwich institutions. Many of CSD’s sandwich options are fairly heavy and even calorie-dense, but only a few really go over the top. I appreciate that moderation.

Veggie burger in panini form

Vegetarian sandwich with a side of slaw (from last time)

A staff that cares. On my most recent visit, I opted for a veggie burger. In side-stepping my tendency to stick to the menu, I made some requests: a single patty (who needs two?) and deli mustard to replace the honey mustard. The girl behind the counter took ownership from there—pushing for slices of bread instead of a baguette after I requested the panini option. Her comment: this is going to be the best black bean burger you’ve had. Whether or not it’s true (or she even meant it), it was a nice gesture. It felt like she actually cared.

Good but not quite healthy. Aside from my own faulty decision to combine lettuce with a panini press, the sandwich was good. They opted for a black bean patty nearly identical to what you might get from Morning Star Farms—mimicking the only commercial veggie burger I keep on hand. I opted for pepper jack cheese and whole wheat bread from a loaf that I suspect they had delivered Breadworks (i.e., good bread). The whole thing came together well: plenty of texture from thick slices of bread with the spice of the “burger” still able to through. It wasn’t exceptionally healthy, but I didn’t feel too bad about eating half for dinner. They gave me the flexibility to construct a tasty and reasonably healthy option; really, that’s all I ask.

You should go. It’s no Salt of the Earth or even a Thai Suan Thip, but it doesn’t try to be. Carson Street Deli serves up a nice atmosphere, a clean look, free WiFi, and good beer—not to mention a quality sandwiches (veggie and otherwise). That all rounds up exactly the mix that I look for in a restaurant. The only real downfall: the lack of a decent salad.

If you’re in the South Side and looking for a low key place for good food and beer with minimal fuss, you have every reason to stop in. If you’re looking for a salad or really anything beyond a sandwich, then keep on walking.

A few Friday’s ago, I made plans to meet up with a friend—actually an great new friend that I met through this very blog (Jen). That outing gave me a chance to hang out over a few beers and see two different items on their menu. Definitely a fun trip.

Correction: It seems my memory of the beer special was wrong. The special is actually $2 off, rather than 50%. Given that most of their beers are about $5, that’s not really a huge difference anyway.

The Park House
parkhousepgh.com

403 E Ohio St
Pittsburgh, PA 15212
(412) 231-0551

In case you’ve missed it all these years, the Park House is up on the North Side—a part of town I’ve only recently started to discover. It’s a bar, though one with an a great selection of craft beer. Except craft beer isn’t all they can offer. The Park House also offers up a full menu with a few twists and turns from what you might normally expect at what is largely a North Side bar. Most notably, the menu lists a decent number of veggie options. Sadly, though, the one item that I was most excited to try is no longer available: the “Eat your veggies or go in the corner” spinach-lentil sandwich. When I asked for one, there was some uncertainty over whether it was even available.

One more thing: after this visit, I already have a favorite Park House anecdote. While waiting for Jen, the bar tender described the happy hour special as half $2 off all beer except a few listed macrobrewed “lite” lagers. Nice.

Doesn’t it look like a fancy restaurant from the street? Judging from the black canopy and old wooden doors and just peering into the darkness beyond the windows, my brain almost categorized the place as one of those quaint little restaurants where everyone sits quietly at cloth-laden tables. Thankfully, I couldn’t have been more wrong. In discussing free peanuts, the web site calls the place a “throw your-shells-on-the-floor kind of place. That just about sums it up.

Once you do get in side, the bar runs down the left side of most of the length of the restaurant, and there’s only really one row of seating beside it. In the far back, there’s a little bit more space for some larger tables. Presumably, that’s where the live music gets to set up.

Table kitch. If you zoom in to the tables, the first thing to catch your eye is likely the little peg-board games. If you’ve ever been to a Cracker Barrel, you’ve seen it before. It’s basically the same game (and that might even be where they bought them). Another cool detail that didn’t show up until later: Jen and I both ordered water, and ended up with a re-purposed vodka bottle serving as pitcher on our table. Both the game and the bottle served as nice little touches.

Most of the place in a single frame.

Not a bad-lookin' watcher pitcher.

Veggie sightings all over the menu. Just walking through the menu was kind of exciting. Mixed in among all the standard bar food that you would expect were a significant number of veggie-friendly options. I noted Falafel (both entree and sandwich options), a “Peace in the Middle East” Platter, a hummus appetizer (with a choice of hummus flavors in what could only be made in house), and a Spinach Burrito. The menu boasts a house-made veggie burger (constructed with spinach and lentils), but I was told they were weaving in and out of having that one on the menu and didn’t have any available when I showed up.

That they list some veggie-friendly (and semi-healthy) options to go with gives me hope that the non-veg options are at least presented with some careful attention. In a pinch, I’d probably even order one of the non-veg items (and still might just to give it a try).

The posted menu from the main entrance.

Peanuts and popcorn. Help yourself in the back.

Free peanuts and popcorn. While you’re waiting for food, you can help yourself to free peanuts and/or popcorn. Jen picked up some of each. They’re no frills snacks, but I think it’s a nice touch. They kind of reminded me of Friday night outings with my family when I was a kid. Turns out, when you’re not old enough to drink, the peanuts and popcorn are the most exciting aspect of any bar.

Across the table: a falafel sandwich. First off, Jen’s falafel sandwich looked amazing (making me enormously jealous). She was quite pleased with it, so I’ll definitely give it a try next time.

The falafel sandwich that I need to try.

Pretty decent Almost heaven Spinach Burrito. After dealing with the blow of rejection from the “Eat your veggies…” veggie burger, I switched my order over to the Almost Heaven Spinach Burrito. I was a little nervous the thing would show up overstuffed with filling, but it came out just the opposite: the tortilla hung like a baggy pair of pants around the well-portioned veggie mixture. I’ll take it.

In terms of actual content, the contents were primarily spinach with some onions, tomatoes and mushrooms in there somewhere. The cheddar cheese made it’s appearance as a melted layer on the inside of the tortilla. I’m guessing it had ben melted into place pre-assembly.

I came out only semi-positive on this wrap, but I’m certainly not going to write the place off as a result. I think it made for a solid veggie choice with a pretty well-rounded flavor. Overall, it’s a fairly healthy option with a controlled level of cheese—though leaning closer to too much than not enough. Even so, it wasn’t much to write home about. According to the web site, they’d gladly have hit it up with salsa or a number of dressings—including a balsamic vinaigrette. It sounds like next time, I’d definitely request the salsa (or perhaps the balsamic) for some extra depth.

The "Almost Heaven" Spinach Burrito

It was the beer that finally lead me in. I’ll be honest: references to the Park House didn’t manage to pull me out there until after I heard that they had both good food and lots of craft beer options. My sources were right: I counted at least 16 taps with the vast majority going to craft beer. To pair with that quantity, the bar tender was able to drop some pretty decent ideas in discussing options for my second beer. Between his recommendations and that enthusastic expression of the happy hour special, I got the impression that they at least had a decent handle on the beer. Just remember, half $2 off all beer—except for miller light, PBR and any other macro-brews.

At least 16 taps. Many good options.

I’ll definitely be heading back. It’s not often that I find a bar flowing with veggie options, reasonably healthy options, and a downright enthusiasm toward good beer. In my book, the three elements combined pull the Park House into the category of must-try. That will likely remain true as long as you’re looking for a fun place to grab a beer that won’t frown on a healthy lifestyle. On the other hand, it’s harder to make the must-try case if you’re just in it for the food. After all, if you’re just looking for good food, then, by all means, go somewhere other than a bar!

Having just recently opened, there’s very little out in the way of reviews, so I’ll see what I can do about fully documenting the place. The most I’ve seen is a quick write-up from Bob Batz. If you want to try yourself, the Beer Meetup is making their way out at the end of the month (August 2010).

NOTE: I didn’t pay for this meal. I was invited by Tavern 245 to sample their menu, and stopped by to do just that and discuss the restaurant with their lead PR person and a few other employees. Of course, everything in this post is my own opinion. I just think it’s important to disclose that kind of detail.

Tavern 245 ($$)
www.tavern245.com

245 Fourth Ave
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
(412) 281-4345

You can find Tavern 245 on 4th Avenue—right near PPG Place and Market Square. I’m not familiar with that area, so I wandered a little bit, but once I turned onto 4th, it was hard to miss: they spared no expense in a massive 3-dimensional sign hanging over the front door. The restaurant just opened within the past few weeks (July 2010), and, true to the name, it’s a Pub/Tavern—though more of an upscale casual one. Despite the up-scale feel, the menu’s focus on pub fare (sandwiches, burgers, and various small plates) keeps the prices more than reasonable.

Oh, and the beer list: it’s definitely impressive. They certainly don’t qualify as a “beer destination” but they serve up enough craft beer options to draw me in any time.

Downstairs bar. Upstairs lounge. When you first walk in the door, you’re presented with two choices: head upstairs or open the door to the downstairs bar. Choose wisely: in almost all cases, you probably want to go up, which will take you to the main bar/dining room. The primary use case for the downstairs bar seems to be smoking. The space is separately ventilated, so they’re able to open it up to smokers. The beer list down there leans away from craft beer options—with the possible exception of Sam Adams, though the setup is still just as “loungy” as the space upstairs.

If you choose the upstairs destination (and you should), you’ll find a fairly large space with a mid-sized bar, a few different clusters of small tables, some booths, and multiple lounge areas—complete with couches and flat screens. Beyond the bar, a final cluster of tables gets a view out a large window opening up to 4th Avenue. Besides the light coming in off the street, the dining room is fairly dim with just a few small lamps scattered throughout. It actually feels kind of like a stylish living room with a few pockets of artifacts sitting out on end tables and hanging on the walls.

The downstairs bar. No craft beer on tap.

The Upstairs Dining Room

A Lounge near the 4th Avenue Window

The staff: laid back and talkative. Even before I stepped into the restaurant, I bumped into the manager and co-owner, Chip hanging outside with a few members of the staff. We exchanged introductions fairly quickly before he showed me in and let me glance over the downstairs bar. I don’t even think he was out there intending to show me in—my primary contact was still waiting for me upstairs. In any case, that same friendly/talkative vibe seemed to flow from just about every employee I bumped into. Significantly, every last person I talked to exposed how much they enjoyed working for Chip—from the wait staff to the executive chef. That kind of detail is important when I decide which restaurants I like to support and visit. A positive work environment makes me appreciate any place just a little bit more.

It’s a tavern, and the menu follows. The menu is brief. It’s also available in full online (also, in PDF). A skim through reveals some familiar pub fair—focussed on appetizers, sandwiches, and burgers. Thankfully, they throw a few salads in to top it off. They’ll also serve any sandwich as a wrap.

Veggie options (good ones) by request. I’ll be honest, it’s not the most veggie-friendly menu in the world. My contact person, Jenn even admitted a little concern when I warned her in an email message about my veggie/healthy leanings. If you consume fish, then it’s not to hard to find something. That task gets a little more challenging for straight vegetarians, but they didn’t have any trouble whipping out a veggie filling for their 4th Street Tacos. I’ve you’re a full-on vegan, well…you’re prettymuch lost (and they’ll admit it).

Because the whole point was to let me try the place, they let me try a bunch of different menu items. Basically, I sat down with Jenn and ordered some combination of items that caught my attention and her suggestions. I’ll walk through each item separately below.

First, my favorite: 4th Avenue Tacos. These were perhaps my favorite. Served on little corn tortillas from Reyna’s, the menu offers three different fillings (shrimp/chicken/beef) but Jenn was quick to point out an undocumented 4th: vegetarian. I tried shrimp and veggie and had a bite of chicken. The veggies were my definite favorite, so it’s definitely worth asking for.

Next, something different: Smoked Chipotle Hummus. Served with pita chips, this definitely wins the award for the most unique hummus flavor I’ve enjoyed. With mixed in tomatoes, the dip has a rather untraditional texture. The flavor lays down a unique tone as well: smokey up front with a chipotle heat that swoops in from behind. With a level of spice that jumped beyond my expectation for an unassuming appetizer, this was definitely worth sampling.

While I’m on dips, the Guacamole 245. Not much to say here, other than the dip being served at a soothing cool temperature and offering a pleasing contrast with the hummus’s heat. I prefer the hummus, but this was definitely a hand-made guac that I’m told used juice from both lemon and lime to give it a little depth of flavor. If you’re into the avacado standard, you’ll most likely enjoy.

Fourth Avenue Tacos

Chipotle Hummus

Guacamole

The main event: a Salmon Burger (in wrap form). After a beer and a few bites of various appetizers, I was already satiated but moved on to sample a bit of the day’s special: a salmon burger transformed to embrace 245′s wrap option. A house-prepared salmon patty lightly breaded and wrapped up with lettuce/tomato/onion and a dash of mayo. Yeah, I felt a little guilty about the mayo, but this one was packed with flavor. To me, that’s a big vote of confidence for the wrap option.

Because I had to try a salad: the House Salad. There’s a reason I tend to order salads. It’s one of my favorite dinner options. You might say I’m on a quest for all the good salads in Pittsburgh. In the side salad category, this was definitely a good one. Simple, yes; finely chopped, yes. It featured tiny pieces of leaf lettuce, cucumber, tomato and red onion—all topped with a somewhat overdone handful of grated parmesan. With the mound of grated cheese, the balsamic vinaigrette was hardly even necessary (though made in house, like all of 245′s dressings). It would have been a touch more exciting with a few thin peels of hard parmesan, but that’s likely cost prohibitive.

Wrap option for a Salmon Burger (the day's special)

House Salad (with a tad too much parmesan)

Not a beer destination, but worth visiting. With the downtown Sharp Edge not too far away, this is hardly a local beer destination. That said, the strong focus on craft brews and quality recommendations from the bar tender, I can’t imagine not being pleased with their selection. In a part of town where many destinations focus on wine and toss out just one or two craft beer options, Tavern 245 almost stands out. They could definitely fill up Downtown’s Market Street Ale House gap.

An enjoyable recommendation from the bar tender

Worth heading downtown for. Having been comped a meal, you won’t really trust my opinion; I know that. I will say that I liked the place. They serve up a casual atmosphere, friendly staff. and a menu that I could enjoy. You might have to work at trying to be a little healthy and put in special requests to stick to a vegetarian diet, but I’d definitely go back. With their late hours, I’d even make a trip downtown for them. I’d say this one is definitely worth a try (though leaning on must-try since it’s brand new).

It’s been a few (busy) weeks, but I’ll take a stab at writing down some of my thoughts. Consider this post a starting point. I tend to be biased against the food at any Sharp Edge just because they lack much in the way of healthy options or veggie-centric dishes. The new place has some new options, but I still had a somewhat negative food experience in this trip. My hope (and expectation) is that I can write that off to the new kitchen still finding it’s way. A trip back will likely be a better indicator.

The Sharp Edge Bistro on Penn
www.sharpedgebeer.com

922 Penn Avenue
Pittsburgh, PA 15222
412-338-2437

For anyone who doesn’t follow the local beer scene, The Sharp Edge now has 5 locations throughout the city. Long before interest in craft beer really started to explode, The Sharp Edge was serving up a huge variety of hard-to-come-by Belgian beers—starting from their original location in East Liberty, the “Beer Emporium.” The menu very much follows suit: plenty of Belgian-inspired dishes along side some individually prepared pizzas that I’m told are quite a hit (and half price during happy hour). Also half price during happy hour: Belgian Drafts. If you can show up before 6:30, you probably won’t be disappointed.

Two categories, one beer market. Now let me back up a bit: “rare imported Belgians” is very much distinct from “American Craft Beer,” but they capture a very similar spirit (and almost the same market). Starting not too long ago, the two scenes even started to merge as craft brewers grew an interest in playing with Belgian styles and even cooperating with Belgian brewers. The Sharp Edge own Over the Edge, contracted through a Belgian brewer is evidence of that cross pollination: a Belgian IPA.

Fits right in with Penn Ave. The most striking aspect of the new setting is the fact that it melds in quite well in a row of somewhat upscale establishments in the cultural district. I’ve read that the downtown location most closely resembles the Bistro in Sewickley, which is also supposed to be a higher end place. In this case, their Penn Avenue neighbors include the likes of Nine on Nine, Sonoma Grille, and Seviche—all on the up-scale side of the fence. I tend to think of any Sharp Edge as far more approachable than any of those; if you ignore the rather expensive beer, the new location lists prices in line with other Sharp Edge locations—probably less than their Penn Avenue neighbors.

Key to fitting in is clearly the enormous array of windows in front, which shows off an inviting sitting area beside the bar. On the Friday evening I stopped by, there was little chance of finding a spot on the couch or up at the bar, but I’ve been told (and would have to expect) that’s not always the case. I hear that a little earlier on Friday (4pm) and even on week nights, it’s not very hard to find a spot at either.

The Cozy Seating Area (with a friend waving me in)

One of Several 5-Tap Units

Impressive bar area. In comparison to other locations, the bar area was quite impressive—more so than the section of the dining area that I sat in. Several clusters of 5-tap fixture were spread out evenly across the whole bar area with a backdrop containing both a visual bottle list and (faux?) brick backdrop. With plenty of space behind for the bar tenders and wait staff and a dark marble countertop, the whole thing looked quite impressive.

Familiar dining area. The dining area had a completely different feel from the bar. In fact, it reminds me a lot of some of the other new-ish Sharp Edge locations—Brasserie being a good example. Separated by a partial wall, the dining is clean with orderly tables (and plenty of space between). With nearly half the width of the restaurant dedicated to the bar, the downtown dining area seemed a little bit “thin” but not really small. The separator between dining room and bar actually did that did a pretty good job of isolating noise.

Looks familiar, doesn't it?

Some (new?) veggie-friendly salads. In terms of the menu, I had heard about a new menu for the new location—one that will possibly be pushed out to the remaining locations. I’d say the format looked completely different, but the contents were somewhat familiar. In their defense, The salad section did seem to see more revisions and even included many veggie-friendly options. There’s even a portobello option on the “deluxe salad,” which I don’t recall from the previous menu. Other veggie-friendly salad options: House, Field Greens, Spinach, and The Edge Stack Salad. Of those, I seem to remember only the house and spinach option. The others may or may not be new.

A disappointing but optimistic look at the food. Despite the new salad options, I wanted to avoid actually try something more typical of the typical Sharp Edge fare: I went with a panini/soup combo. The panini: a grilled veggie option that has actually existed for a while; the soup: a crab chowder that happened to be in rotation that night. Unfortunately, I wasn’t very thrilled with either.

The Panini. The panini wasn’t really what I was looking for. The flavor was good, but the quantity of veggies within was relatively small. I would have liked to see more. The goat cheese could have been a nice touch with a lighter hand, but it was oozing and dripping like crazy while I tried to eat. Personally, I think goat cheese should have a texture, so heating to the point of melting (though easy), isn’t what I would want. Beyond that, it was far too much cheese to be considered a light option (which I always hope the veggie options can turn out to be).

The crab chowder. First, be warned that this particular chowder included bacon. I have no problem with that, but some probably might. Beyond the bacon, the crab chowder looked like a pretty good cup of soup: plenty of texture from a fairly dense treatment of crab and a decent mix of potato and corn to complement. The only problem I ran into is something that was fairly easy to correct (and I’m guessing they will): it was tremendously salty. It was really so salty that I ended up leaving most of it behind, which was a shame. I’m hoping I can write that experience off with the fact that they had only opened up that week.

Crab Chowder and a Grilled Veggie Panini

A Well-Received Buffalo Burger

Burger form across the table. My friend across the table ordered a buffalo burger, which has always been a favorite of several friends. It looked to me like a solid burger, and he confirmed that it was indeed quite good. He was even a little surprised by my own somewhat negative experience. From what I’ve heard, the burger option is always a good choice after the appetizer specials end and pizza is no longer a cheap option.

A typical Sharp Edge beer list. In terms of beer, there’s not much to say. The selection is very similar to any existing Sharp Edge: plenty of imported Belgian drafts along side a handful of american craft beers and an enormous bottle selection. It’s a great place for imports, but can sometimes be hard to find a more sessionable option: there are plenty of ABV’s floating around throughout the list.

Sad to see beer behind bars, but that's Downtown

Cautious optimism. Despite the fact that I didn’t have much success with the food, I have pretty high hopes for the downtown Sharp Edge. I’m a big supporter of re-vitalizing the downtown area, and it seems that a Sharp Edge entrant could entice an audience that otherwise might not spend time downtown. Downtown is really hurting for a good beer destination. With the Market Street Ale House long since gone (and replaced by a less beer-focused Las Velas), there’s really wasn’t a notable beer option anywhere downtown. The Sharp Edge is a good beer option and then some, and I’ll definitely be heading back to give the food another try.